3 Bank of Americas Attacked in Santa Cruz
We chose Bank of America because of their exemplary demonstration of capitalism’s principles (sic). Funding toxic coal projects, selling out workers, in bed with the government… Rather than many banks who worship money over people, we chose to stick it to one bank that worships money more than people. After all, it is a bank. But we’ll be back.
Anarchists
i read that the attack on a B of A in olympia was in solidarity with the workers.
Maybe these were too.
Oh well, time to invest in shatterproof glass, I guess...
Vandalism, while a classic means for dissenters, hardly targets the source of the issues you're claiming to combat. What results from something like this is that some poor guy now has to go out and clean up while the bank itself receives sympathy from those who may disagree with their practices but who view this particular brand of activism as reactionary and juvenile. If this is the best you can come up with, what really takes a hit is my hope for change.
Besides, how is it not entirely hypocritical to respond to people being killed by cops by taking violent action? You are doing your own cause a disservice by sinking to the level of the same breed of smuck you claim to despise.
Of course in the U.S. we're much more civilized and have more respect for our banks and law enforcement authorities. We realize that a patient trust in President Obama will lead to a quick withdrawal from Iraq, peace in Afghanistan, an end to the U.S. military's collateral murder of civilians in Pakistan, and nuclear disarmnament.
And locally the Santa Cruz City Council under Mayor Mathews and Vice-Mayor Rotkin will return with meaningful cuts in the six-figure salaries of real powerbrokers in the city like City-Manager-for-Life Dick Wilson, an end to the intrusive and obvious overpolicing downtown, taxes on real estate speculation and other forms of predatory wealth, and a transparent responsive government at last open to all.
All kidding aside, those who rage at violence against property have a responsibility to provide alternatives to those who are losing their homes, their health, and their liberties.
The store owners and car owners... Why did they deserve to have their property destroyed?
Greece, a country where the government debt is 93% of the GDP, and now instead of being able to spend money on services, they have to spend it on rebuilding and funding the police.
The fact remains that these acts of vandalism never further a cause. If violence is the only way you can articulate your argument, you'd be doing the cause a favor by doing nothing at all.
Same thing here, I (like most) don't care what BofA did wrong, I now support BofA simply because they are now the victim to some self-righteous "freedom fighter" who thinks they can dictate how other people act through violence (isn't that what people here accuse the government of?).
I would disagree with you on that statement. IMO, the example of liberal first world privelige is some middle class white punk (probably like yourself and certainly like the individual(s) who did this in Santa Cruz) thinking they are radicals and making any significant change in the system because they vandalize a building.
It's a joke. Getting your ya-ya's off breaking glass, but congratulating yourself and justifying it because its "in support of comrades".
Revolting with much fury...is breaking a window in the dark, running away, and then bragging about it on Indy Bay? Talk about liberal first world privilege. Living it 24/7/365....then pretending your a radical because you break a window.
They have a word for your type: poseur.
First of all you are making some pretty bold assumptions about the people who carried out this action. Do you know these people? If not then why are you accusing them of being "white middle class punks?" What about the people smashing bank windows in solidarity with the Greeks in Madrid, Prague, Moscow, Istanbul, Berlin, and London (to name just a few) are they all just a bunch of poseurs to? Or what about the Greeks smashing bank windows, are they just a bunch of middle class punks also? The uprising in Greece has been a huge inspiration to Anarchists and Anti-Capitalists around the world, that is why so many people are taking to the streets to show the Greeks we support them not only in our words, but in our actions to.
Secondly know one has ever claimed that breaking a few bank windows is going to end capitalism, property destruction is just one tactic (out of many) that can be used to bring about social change. This critique of property destruction is just another lame attempt to side track and misrepresent the issue. If you are so concerned about being productive it's ironic that you would choose posting divisive comments on indymedia about other activists. That is some backwards logic
Lastly getting "upset or offended" about a bank being vandalized -- A bank which is currently (or was) trying to screw factory workers in Chicago out of severance pay, as well as having a long history of funding ecocide and vivisection (seems pretty offensive to me) -- is a very liberal mentality. It's upholding the concept of private property, privilege, and capitalism as something sacred that must be protected.
And this statement by you simply reinforces my belief and point: "What about the people smashing bank windows in solidarity with the Greeks in Madrid, Prague, Moscow, Istanbul, Berlin, and London (to name just a few) are they all just a bunch of poseurs to?"
My point being:They aren't in Madrid, Moscow, or Berlin. They're in Santa Cruz, CA. A wealthy, white, upper middle class town. A wealthy town in a wealthy state in a wealthy nation. And these "activists" are living the good life, enjoying all of the benefits that the town offers. But every once in a while, they put on their little black hoodies and Che Guevara underoors, and they go break a window. Then they run home, pull out their $1,500 laptop, and brag about it to the only population that will applaud their action rather than scold or be disgusted: IndyBay.
Poseur. Revel in it.
This double bomb threat reminds me of the tactics used by terrorists in the middle east who set off one bomb and then when help arrives they set off a second bomb. Sickening.
For more info and discussion, see:
http://portland.indymedia.org/en/2008/12/383529.shtml?discuss
Or maybe it is another disturbed rich kid. They make great terrorists. (Or leaders of superpowers.)
http://www.old-picture.com/american-history-1900-1930s/Attack-Street-Wall-1920.htm
They blamed that one on anarchists at first, then when they found out it was some rich guy's angry kid, he got 'treatment.'
That said, Bank of America has done far more damage to itself (and unfortunately, the larger society as a whole), than a thousand "protesters" tossing rocks through windows every weekend ever could... the scale of the numbers here is breathtaking.
Tossing rocks through windows (or shooting them out with a pellet gun - interesting that that instance generated no comment of substance... how about $4,000 apiece in taxpayer dollars for four courthouse windows?) is faux activism - there's no real risk to it: if someone is arrested, there'll be no way to connect the person being arrested to anything more than a single act of vandalism. Most likely, a misdemeanor, a few days in jail (at most), and a fine (cost of replacing windows plus a few hundred bucks).
It avoids the real work of activism and politics, which is making a case for why commercial corporations are dangerous institutions, why the commercial banking system needs to be more heavily regulated (if it is permitted to exist), etc. etc. etc. Standing up and making your case to your fellow citizens, and persuading them of the merits of your arguments.
Think about it. While it is clear that these banks are the devil's workshop (e.g. millions of people in the U.S. will be foreclosed in their house and lose their jobs and their children will suffer due to their activities), so it isn't that sad that their window was broken - it makes no sense to think that a political activist would have set a bomb at a bank branch. It was probably a super angry, deranged guy who was wronged by them. There would be zero political advantage in hurting bank branch staff, as tellers are typically paid slightly above minimum wage and are entirely separate from decisionmakers. It was probably someone who hated one of the workers or lost his house.
But any ATF investigators would love the opportunity to justify surveillance of the local hippies, if 'chatter' on the internet seemed to back up this decision.
This sounded like a sophisticated device that was rigged to go off in someone's hand, like on the TV show 24. If you think about it, they sent 19 yr old Austin (forgot last name) in San Diego to jail merely for letting someone link to a bomb instruction on someone else's website via his RaisetheFist website. So, it would be fair to say that few civilians understand complex bomb making, and this would take a specialist. Even the type of thing that ELF does is supposed to be flammable gas plus a spark. They sent Rod Coronado to jail merely for speaking about such concepts in public. In other words, it's not easy to share information about this stuff. People out in the country like to mess around with guns and other things in open fields. If anyone knew how to make something like this Portland device which would not accidentally go off in their hands, they probably had prior knowledge from Iraq, and also time to practice out in a farming area.
But back to the point. We're supposed to also be working on trying to develop some social praxis for the return to communism, but since everyone has failed to do that actions like these are getting advanced in the place of having any real theory and practice to get to where we want to go. I don't see how an action like this one or what happened in Greece really leads us anywhere except back to where we started, or jail, or worse.
It's pretty clear that California will reach that soon for youth, as some counties have 10% official unemployment, which doesn't include under-employed people who can only get 20 hours. Teens and people in their early 20s are rarely counted as unemployed because they can say they're students. The other group that goes uncounted are all the immigrants who do so much of the unappreciated work in our society, and also never get to take advantage of benefits like unemployment and disability payments.
There really is a debate about whether good are poor conditions for the working class are more advantageous for change. People like Chomsky point out that real gains tend to only come during prosperous times, such as when the college students in the 60s didn't have to worry about jobs so they could think about politics and philosophy. Maoists would point out change and many revolutions which occurred under economic pressure. The down side is that under these conditions, things can get torn down, but the badly formed institutions (such as the USSR) move in to replace them.
Read the news, the Greeks have started attacking the protesters in some cases because they're fed up with all the property damage.
Greece reports 70% right now. CA reports about 8%. Go ahead and double that to include part-timers and bad data; we'd still only be at 16%.
...how can you say it's pretty clear were going to increase 4.5 times and reach 70%?
To me, it sounds like your using projective math and predicting the future reality and mood to justify an action that happened in the present.
These issues hit my heart deeply as i have known the realm of marginalized poverty for 34 years as a single mother who never married, has mixed race children and lived on the land growing food, chopping wood, hauling water. I spent 4 months in jail for a Gandhian action against Seabrook Nuke in '82 after Noguns, who did her work for homeless and legalization for decades in Santa Cruz, told me about it. It is an insult to compare Gandhi to any cowards. Ignorance is no excuse for inaccuracy. Get your facts straight or better yet, talk to those who really know the depth of courage required to stand behind one's beliefs willing to die for them unarmed.
I have spent many years supporting traditional Dine (Navajo) at Big Mountain/Black Mesa resisting Peabody Coal Corp and their destructive, genocidal greed. Noguns told me about Big Mountain while i was in jail. Pauline Whitesinger, who speaks only her Dineh Bizaad, has been my life's greatest teacher. It was not about breaking windows, for hogans have none. It has been about living frontline life with deep pride and commitment along with the children, the parents, the elders, the sheep, the corn, the water, the trees. It is about ceremony intertwined with land and life. It is about the well being of all living things and the courage to stand behind defense of sacred land. So the struggle continues and where are the window breakers, i ask? Certainly not hauling water nor chopping wood on the frontlines.
What bothers me about all of this is that where the energy is most needed in the f-ing usa is under addressed. The damned cops have been infiltrating the street thugs since day one. From the WTO to Prague to Genoa to Olympia, the instigators of violence are well funded and happy campers cause too many are addicted to immediate gratification. This way is also white male dominated in amerikkka's realm of so called anti capitalism. The followers of Zerzan and Churchill are blinded by the adrenaline of crashing glass. Stupid. Really, look where the suffering is the greatest in this country, talk to the sufferers and act accordingly. I am so tired of people who act, yet won't own their actions. Since the WTO, people in Oly have been so taken with diversity of tactics. Read violence Churchill-Zerzan style. Read hit and run. Read white guys and the gals who seek their admiration. Time to grow up and take in the whole picture. We need communities of resistance as the Zapatistas so eloquently have called for. That includes ALL living humans and not just the cool youth. Too many are damaged by dominant society concepts of what is "in". I personally respect Rod Coronado and Kaytay Kamansuriek because they have the courage to own their actions, to really be willing to sacrifice majorly to live their beliefs. Gandhi and Pauline Whitesinger are among these heroes and sheroes.
I am willing to give my life for the coming generations in whatever manner deemed necessary by Pauline Whitesinger , Dine resistance leader (sheepdognationrocks and www. blackmesais.org), Romona Morales (the mother of murdered, raped and mutilated Sylvia Elena Morales in Jaurez), by marilyn james (reburied over 70 Sinaixt people in Slocan Valley of BC declared extinct by Canadian Gov., she left Colville rez to reclaim land in BC), Noguns who confronted rednecks at Texas Rainbow in '88 then was run over by one in his 4 x 4 nearly killing her, declaring as she lay on the ground, "no charges, no vengeance, total forgiveness" passed on July 31, 2008), grandmothers who know the course to take but continue to be ignored. Time for the elder Mothers to be heard. TIME TO END RAPE, ABUSE AND UNITE BEYOND ANYTHING EVER SEEN IN USA, MOST PRIVILEGED, APATHETIC AND DESTRUCTIVE NATION ON EARTH. IT IS TIME TO TAKE ON THE STRUGGLE WITH HEART.
The actions of those in Greece is beyond the reality of us window breakers. 70% unemployment among Greek youth is not what we have yet approached here. If there was a sensible movement, we would be massive, but it is tired and worn out. Tired and worn out. Try including all elements of the oppressed. ALL. Seems that too many are seeking a CSI thrill rather than solution.
BoA could give a shit about some broken windows. Really. Break some sod and plant some food for those who are starving. Feed the frontliners.
To scoff nonviolence is to scoff birthing mothers, nursing mothers, those of us who have continued mothering on the frontlines of life with our nursing young. We are the ignored and we carry chunks of how to get out of this mess, but we are among those with credentials in the form of callouses upon our hands and hearts. It is our time to be heard and heeded.
Noguns was a pivotal influence introducing me to radical, frontline mothering, performance art, simple living, support of Indigenous Hopi and Dine and nonviolence in the most creative, resistant form possible. May her memory be treasured.
In peaceful struggle,
swaneagle
We chose the Pacific Ocean because of its exemplary demonstration of the laws of physics, in particular wave motion. Light also travels as waves and we thus consider waves to be at least partially responsible for the fact that light does not penetrate wood panels. Rather than all of physics (which worships reality over wishful thinking), we chose to stick it to fluid mechanics (which worships reality over wishful thinking). After all, it's physics. But we'll be back.
Scientists
I really appreciate your comments and the spirit in which they were made. I'm personally thrilled about the riots in Greece, and I see actions like the one in Santa Cruz as important messages of support to our comrades over there. I think it's good for people to have opportunities to lash out at the institutions of capitalism without having to prove the effectiveness of their actions. Not everyone who does that is well-funded or a happy camper. But you're right that a lot of those people (myself included) come from some degree of privilege and take it for granted. You're right that we'll need a lot of humility to move past that attitude. I'm committed to trying, though, and reading your comments has renewed that commitment for me.
What I'm wondering is, do you think there's a way for kids like me or like the window-breakers to connect with the elders without denying what we're about? To meet the gaze of other people on other frontlines (the wood-chopping, water-carrying frontlines), and find ways that we can support each other? That's what real diversity of tactics would mean to me. There's always going to be kids who want to riot, as long as this capitalist machine-world exists and makes us miserable. Can you imagine a way for us to still respect each other as multiple, different communities of resistance?
In solidarity,
A
Say, I'm against the riots, where is the Indymedia office so I can throw some rocks through the window? After all, violence is a perfectly acceptable method of voicing my beliefs, right?
To that end, I'll also need the address of Greenpeace and PETA along with a slingshot and the location of a quarry...
This could be fun, I'm sure to make a real tangible difference via property destruction now!
Odds are, they aren't quite dumb enough to believe that riots and vandalism make a difference.
The only thing that's going to change in Greece is a country that's already way beyond being out of money now gets to spend money rebuilding, and paying medical bills for cops.
It won't change anything an election wouldn't have changed.
And for something a bit more domestic, I would refer you to L.A and Washington D.C, two places that never recovered from their riots, especially Washington D.C.
If you want to make a difference, you'll have to convince people with a decent argument, a rock threw a window is only going to piss people off.
"Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent." The brave rock throwers of Santa Cruz are proving Asimov's quote to be very accurate.
... but it's a step in the right direction.
I can't stomach people who insist that opposition to the mass murderers who run this society must be non-violent. The shame of the movement in the U.S. against the U.S. War on Vietnam was that, while several million Vietnamese died in Vietnam, either resisting U.S. aggression or just being there, only a handful of U.S. war resisters and, to the best of my knowledge, not one war criminal, died in the U.S.. In other words, we never did bring the war home.*
My one problem with the people who posted this item is that they make the same mistake that the Weather Underground made: they come across as self-aggrandizing. This turns off people who might otherwise be encouraged to follow, and perhaps magnify, their example.
* I'm not arguing that the deaths of more U.S. war resisters would have been a good thing. But the fact that there were so few such deaths is a reflection of the fact that we let the Vietnamese do all the dying while we pretty much kept ourselves safe even when that meant being relatively ineffective in impeding the war.
The reason young people are the last hired is because, in general, they have no experience doing real work. Having interviewed many young people for entry level jobs, I've found those who've never worked a job just don't understand what it means to be employed. For example, teens and young adults are oblivious to how chatting on your phone with your friends while on the clock looks; Then you finish your conversation and demand a raise.
Teens that are part of a work-study program are often great hires despite the lack of experience. At least they've had some instruction on the most basic expectations of an employer. I encourage any young person having a hard time holding down a job to take part in your school's work-study program or contact CalJobs to find out what programs they offer.
Good luck- there's a lot more to life than breaking windows.
I think that being of service to frontline Indigenous elders is an education in itself. To participate in living with those who so cared for these lands til invaders came and ruined it all in a matter of a few hundred years is rare and approaching outright extinction. Many of those who have gone to be on the land supporters at Big Mountain/Black Mesa are anarchists with differing views. The question is how willing are you to take direction from those who live daily resistance to the corporate-military genocidal machine? You can be yourself, but the help needed may not match what anyone else thinks. I learned more about human rights, ancient land based ways and awe inspiring humor infused courage at Big Mountain than anywhere else i have struggled. It is fasting disappearing as so many of the resisters i have worked with have passed on. Precious and harsh experiences await those who dare. check out http://www.blackmesais.org
I just wonder how much more inspired the Greek resisters would be by LONG TERM, POWERFUL, NONSTOP RESISTANCE BY AMERICAN ACTIVISTS? Just isn't happening on the scale it needs to. I hope we do that and live frontline communities by camping in the streets by the millions til the mess is cleaned up all over the planet. Life as usual is gone. I would like to see my children inspired to act. They are worn out by my life of struggle and i am old.
I appreciate your perspective.
Peace, swaneagole
I was just in Greece this summer, and I thought it odd the police only had a gun and a pair of handcuffs on their belt... Say what you want about American cops, but I'd much rather get shot by a taser than by a gun.
Ultimately, riots turn away otherwise sympathetic people. Greece is a democracy, just like America -- bad things happen not because the system is unjust, but because people are apathetic. If we wanted change, we could vote it in, but most people live comfortable lives and can't be bothered to know more than what they might accidentally see on the cover of Time magazine while waiting to check out.
It is my wish to see a widespread general strike where such corps like BoA are boycotted out of existence. We need to take to the streets and NOT leave til justice is instituted. Obama is more of the same, Bush lite with darker skin, sad to say. He keeps appointing corporatists. Big surprise considering coal and nuclear industries put him in office in the first place.
I believe we must ACT powerfully and with the greatest integrity. Trouble with marauders is that they answer to no one and innocents too often are nabbed. Can mass integrity be utilized to stand with utter courage for what is right ever be enacted? I am not afraid to die, but i do not wish to act alone as i have for so many years. Can people come together for the sake of the future and leave a magic memory that actually accomplishes true justice? If humans can go to the moon, why can we not get out of this mess with full tilt soul force?
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.